What questions should an LP ask an emerging venture manager?

Evaluating managers
Written By

Ask questions that test whether the evidence supports the story. A good first meeting with an emerging manager covers three things: the investment case (what the fund will do and why this team can do it), the firm behind the fund (who carries out the work and how the business runs), and the fit with your own portfolio (whether this fund does something your program needs). The questions below are organized that way, with a note on what a strong answer usually contains.

Why the questions matter more with an emerging manager

An established manager arrives with years of fund-level results you can study. A first- or second-time manager usually does not, so more of your judgment rests on evidence you have to gather in conversation: how decisions were made, who made them, and whether the plan fits the people and capital behind it. Cambridge Associates, describing its own venture practice, notes that a majority of top-quartile performers in a given vintage are emerging managers raising one of their first few funds. That is a reason to look closely, not a reason to assume any particular manager belongs in that group.

Questions about the investment case

These test whether the strategy is specific, repeatable and supported by evidence.

  • What do you do that a larger or better-known fund cannot do as well? A strong answer names a specific access point, stage or market and explains why it persists.
  • Where did your last ten investments come from? You are listening for a sourcing channel that repeats, and for the share of deals that came through it rather than through a general network.
  • Walk me through one investment you declined and why. Selection is visible in the deals a manager passes on, not only in the ones that worked.
  • How did you size the fund, and what does the plan assume about check size, ownership and reserves? The numbers should connect. A fund that targets high ownership with small checks at high valuations has a tension worth discussing.
  • What would make you change the strategy midway through the fund? This shows whether the manager has thought about drift and what would justify it.

Questions about the firm behind the fund

These test whether the organization can carry out the strategy for ten years or more.

  • Who decides, and how? Ask how the investment committee works, who can say no, and how disagreements are resolved.
  • Which decisions in your prior record were yours? Attribution matters most when the record comes from a previous firm. Our guide on reading a prior-firm track record covers this in detail.
  • Who handles the fund's administration, audit, legal and compliance work? Ask for named providers that are engaged today, not providers the manager intends to hire.
  • How many board seats will each partner hold at the end of the investment period? Board work accumulates and rarely retires on schedule.
  • What happens if one partner cannot continue? The answer should cover both the key-person clause and the practical plan for running the fund.

Questions about the fit with your portfolio

These are questions you ask yourself as much as the manager.

  • What does this fund add that my current managers do not? Stage, geography, sector or access can each be a legitimate answer.
  • How large would my commitment be relative to the fund? Being the largest investor in a small fund changes your governance role and your concentration.
  • Would I want to re-up, and what would I need to see? A first commitment to an emerging manager is often the start of a relationship across several funds.
  • What are the terms, and are they normal for this stage? Fees, carried interest, GP commitment and side letters each deserve a look. Our guide to normal venture fund fees and carried interest is a starting point.

What a strong answer sounds like

Strong answers are specific and checkable. A manager who says "we have proprietary deal flow" has told you little. A manager who says "eight of our last twelve investments came from founders we backed as angels, and here are their names" has given you something you can verify through references. Strong answers also name limits: what the record does not show yet, which part of the plan is still an assumption, and what the manager is doing about it. Candor about gaps is usually a better signal than a pitch with none.

Questions that rarely help

Some questions produce rehearsed answers without telling you much. Asking a manager to predict returns, or to name the next breakout company, mostly tests confidence. Asking for a generic description of "value add" tends to produce a list of services. You will learn more by asking for a specific example of the support they gave a company in a difficult quarter, and then checking it with the founder.

Adjust the questions to your own process

A family office with a principal who decides quickly will weigh these questions differently from a foundation with an investment committee. If you report to a committee, think about which answers you will need to defend in that room and press on those first. Our guide on explaining a newer manager to an investment committee covers that conversation.

Related questions

Weighing a manager right now?

Send us the manager you are considering and Dr. Itzel Moncada will give you a free second read on whether their plan holds together and what to ask next. Request a Second Read, or see how we work with allocators.

Sources

The questions above are a starting framework drawn from these sources and from Colibrí Strategies' practice. They are not a checklist that every institution applies, and no list replaces diligence on the specific manager.